2 min read

Gauge Your Feedback to Understand How it's Landing for Others

Gauge Your Feedback to Understand How it's Landing for Others

Table of Contents

We want to help you create a culture of great feedback. In order to do that, we think you need to give feedback, get feedback, encourage feedback and gauge your feedback.

Feedback: Get it. Give it. Gauge it. Encourage it.

Get it

You have to work hard to get candid feedback from the people you work with, especially if you’re the boss. Hearing no criticism from your team doesn’t mean there isn’t any - it just means they’re not sharing it. Start with a simple question, such as “Can you give me some advice?” and then shut up and listen with the intent to understand.

Give it

Give feedback that shows you Care Personally and are willing to Challenge Directly. Try our HIP approach to giving Radically Candid feedback.

Gauge it

Radical Candor is not measured at your mouth; it’s measured at the listener’s ear. Gauging how your feedback is landing will enable you to know how other people are experiencing your feedback and will help you move toward being more Radically Candid.

Encourage it

Feedback becomes an integral part of your company culture when you encourage it among all team members. Help everyone learn to give each other in person, impromptu praise and criticism so that your organization can improve itself quickly and your team can be even more engaged than they already are.

--

Training and workshops are important, but we’ve found that their impact tends to be ephemeral. The absolute best training day sees the students run out of the room, eager to change behavior and implement new ideas with haste.

Maybe a week later, though, the enthusiasm wanes and your students are back to old habits. It’s a disappointing cycle and sometimes can make even the best training sessions feel like a waste of time and money.

Similarly, when you go to your semi-annual cleaning at the dentist, you walk out of the building feeling like the Pearl Drops lady. Included with your cleaning is a finger-wag from the hygienist about your need to brush and floss more often - because that’s where the real impact comes from. The cleaning matters, but it can’t hold up on its own.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IF3A3u2hYL4&feature=youtu.be&t=20s

So how can you make sure that a culture of feedback persists in your company, after you introduce the concepts of Radical Candor? Gauge your feedback regularly.

Why Gauge Your Feedback?

  1. Get the superpower to know what others think - Of course you want to know what others think about your feedback. You know that Radical Candor is measured at the listener’s ear and not at your mouth, so you need the listener’s perspective. Asking them to gauge your feedback will show you whether you’ve been Radically Candid - or not - in the last week.
  2. Knowing is half the battle - GI Joe said “Knowing is half the battle.” If you ask people to gauge your feedback each week, it will help you remember to give impromptu praise and criticism. Plus, just knowing how people rate your feedback will help you naturally improve.

https://youtu.be/tCRCX2pItAg

  1. Small investment, big rewards - It takes less than a minute for you to ask people to gauge your feedback, and even less time for them to do it. And when they do gauge your feedback, you’ll both notice a big improvement in your working relationship.
  2. Get tips and advice - When you learn how your feedback is perceived, you’ll know what you need to improve and can check out specific tips for moving towards Radical Candor.

You can learn how people feel about your feedback by printing out the Radical Candor framework and asking them to mark their ratings.

Key Questions Covered

What does it mean to 'gauge' your feedback in the Radical Candor framework?

Gauging your feedback means actively checking in to understand how your feedback is landing with the people you work with. As the post puts it, Radical Candor is measured at the listener's ear, not at your mouth. That means your intent doesn't matter as much as the other person's experience. By regularly asking colleagues to rate or reflect on your feedback — even using something as simple as the printed Radical Candor framework — you can see whether you're coming across as Radically Candid or falling into one of the other quadrants.

How do I actually ask someone to gauge my feedback without making it awkward?

Keep it simple and low-stakes. The post suggests it takes less than a minute to ask — you can hand someone the Radical Candor framework and ask them to mark where they think your recent feedback landed. You're not asking for a performance review; you're just inviting a quick, honest reaction. The more casual and routine you make it, the less awkward it feels. Over time, this kind of check-in becomes a natural part of how your team communicates.

Why isn't it enough to just train my team on Radical Candor once?

Because the impact of one-time training tends to fade fast. The post compares it to a dentist cleaning — you leave feeling great, but without daily habits (brushing, flossing), the results don't last. The same is true for feedback culture. A great workshop might energize your team in the moment, but without ongoing practices like gauging feedback weekly, people drift back to old habits. Building feedback into a regular routine is what makes the culture stick.

What are the four things I need to do to build a great feedback culture?

According to the post, you need to do four things: Get feedback by actively soliciting it from your team (they won't always volunteer it, especially to a boss); Give feedback using the Radical Candor HIP approach, balancing personal care with direct challenge; Gauge your feedback to understand how it's actually landing with others; and Encourage feedback across your whole team so it becomes a cultural norm, not just a top-down exercise.

How often should I ask people to gauge my feedback?

The post recommends doing it weekly. Asking people to gauge your feedback on a regular cadence serves two purposes: it keeps you accountable and reminds you to actually give impromptu praise and criticism throughout the week. Knowing that someone will reflect on your feedback soon naturally encourages you to be more intentional about it. And because it takes less than a minute for both parties, the time investment is minimal compared to the improvement it drives.

What do I do after I learn how my feedback is being perceived?

Use the insight to course-correct. The post notes that once you know how people are experiencing your feedback — whether it's landing as Radical Candor or something else — you can look up specific tips for moving in the right direction. If you discover you've been too harsh, you can work on showing more personal care. If you've been too soft, you can practice being more direct. The awareness itself is half the battle, as the post puts it, and naturally drives improvement over time.

Keep going.

Three ways to put this into practice.

Apply what you've learned Get personalized coaching with Compass
Your AI-powered Radical Candor coach. Free to try.
Used by managers at Apple, Dropbox, and Twitter Try Compass free
Stay sharp More like this, every week
Practical leadership tips in your inbox.
Join 25,000+ leaders Subscribe free
For your whole team Bring Radical Candor to your organization
Workshops, keynotes, and rollouts for teams of 50+.
Trusted by 100+ Fortune 500 leadership teams Talk to our team

EXPLORE MORE FROM RADICAL CANDOR

How to Get and Give Feedback Using the Radical Candor Order of Operations

How to Get and Give Feedback Using the Radical Candor Order of Operations

There are four simple steps for how to give and receive feedback you need to excel at work. You might call it the solution to your feedback wipeouts....

Read More
11 Tips for Getting Feedback From Your Employees

11 Tips for Getting Feedback From Your Employees

Managers often ask us how to get feedback from employees. Understanding the best way to get feedback from employees is the first step toward creating...

Read More
Leaders Who Embrace Feedback Training Have Happier, Healthier & More Productive Teams

Leaders Who Embrace Feedback Training Have Happier, Healthier & More Productive Teams

If your feedback has ever failed or fallen flat, you’re in good company. Feedback training for leaders is one of the most overlooked aspects of...

Read More