Blog

3 Steps for Offering Radical Candor to Executives

DILEMMA: 

AI transformation can feel like a horse race between excitement and mistrust, and too often mistrust wins. Operational managers feel caught between mistrust from their employees, who fear the initiatives, and mistrust from their C-suites, who mandate the rollout without understanding the facts on the ground. What can they do? Criticizing executives has always been daunting. And criticizing an executive’s pet AI rollout elicits a special kind of fear in 2026. How can operational managers practice Radical Candor with executives, especially if they haven’t been receptive to criticism in the past?

Step 1: Understand Your Executive's Logic

When your team is criticizing your boss’s pet AI project, you’re in a tough spot, especially if you tend to agree with your team’s POV. The first thing to do is make sure you understand your executive’s logic so well that you could explain it credibly to someone else, even if you don’t agree with it. If you’re not sure how to do that, use the techniques of a Rogerian Argument to expand your perspective.

Step 2: Laugh about AI Fails and Celebrate AI Wins With Your Team.

Frequent failure is essential to innovation. But if you can’t talk about failures, you'll keep making the same damn mistake and get nowhere. And if you don’t celebrate the wins, failure becomes the sole focus, which is too discouraging.

One of the lowest-tech, cheapest, most effective systems for encouraging the radically candid praise and criticism essential to any innovative project uses a couple of stuffed animals to celebrate “Whoops” and “Wins” alike.

A CTO I know brought a stuffed Orca into his all-hands each week to celebrate wins. The idea was to have team members stand up and talk about extraordinary work they’d seen someone else do. Whoever did the most extraordinary thing got to keep the whale on their desk for the week. The previous week's whale winner decided who deserved the whale this week.

 

Gemini_Generated_Image_ag5kd2ag5kd2ag5k

Next, people nominated themselves (NOT others) for “Whoops a Daisy.” If anyone screwed up that week, they could stand up, tell the story, get automatic forgiveness, and help prevent somebody else from making the same mistake.


Gemini_Generated_Image_disindisindisind

I loved this idea and brought it with me to management roles at Juice and Google. In both cases, there was silence when we first started doing it. You could hear crickets. Not knowing what else to do, I put twenty dollars on the table for a whoops story. Once people could pretend that they weren’t copping to my corny stuffed animal but simply wanted that twenty dollars, the stories started pouring out. This practice not only made it safe to make mistakes—and therefore innovate—but also sped up the resolution of problems that otherwise would have festered. It also made it clearer where I could personally get involved to help (instead of assuming). For example, I once learned somebody on my team had deeply offended an executive and that I needed to do some damage control. I knew the executive and could help. Another time, I discovered a mistake that had infuriated a customer who now needed some TLC. Again, I knew the affected customer, and now that I understood the problem, I could help.

The stories that the Whoops and Wins elicited became my favorite part of most all-hands meetings. We all learned a lot in fifteen minutes.

In some industries, like aviation, sharing mistakes is so important that joking about a Whoops with a stuffed daisy would be inappropriate. When a pilot makes a mistake, it could cost hundreds of lives. Yet, pilots are human and will make mistakes. The more they can learn from one another’s mistakes, the safer air travel can be. The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) wanted to figure out how to get pilots sharing information freely after near-misses or crashes. Because the FAA has the authority to revoke pilots' licenses, pilots were unlikely to be forthcoming about mistakes they’d made.

So, the FAA funded a program that NASA administers: the Aviation Safety Reporting System. Retired pilots talk to pilots involved in safety incidents to figure out what happened. As long as the pilots hadn’t been careless or reckless, they were granted immunity for their mistakes. This made them feel safe sharing information, and as a result, we are all a lot safer when we fly.

When the team at Radical Candor started using AI in all our workflows, I got some feedback that my enthusiasm was stressing everyone out. When Peter the Great was trying to Westernize his court, he encouraged people to learn French dances. When people didn’t appear to be having fun, he’d beat them on the head. I realized I’d gone a bit down that path, so we started talking about AI Whoops and AI Wins every week, which accomplished several important things.

  1. Catharsis. Some of the AI Whoops were hilarious, and it felt good to tell the stories.
  2. Solidarity. We are all in this together, trying to figure it out.
  3. Imagine problems before they happen to us. We all get lulled into a false sense of complacency when our AI agents finally work. We start to rely on them before they’ve proven they’re reliable, stop double-checking, and miss mistakes. Anecdotes about other people’s disasters let you learn the easy way what they learned the hard way.
  4. Inspiration. One person’s win might trigger an idea for you. Or maybe you can just use the agent. Agents scale!
  5. Explanatory anecdotes. Hearing weekly anecdotes keeps me grounded in what’s really happening. And if I had a boss with a different POV from mine on AI transformation, my team's anecdotes would be the best way for me to explain why I believe what I believe. Sharing facts on the ground does a lot of the persuasive work.

Step 3: Share Stories about AI Fails and Wins with Your Executive

In a culture that doesn't accept criticism, people will probably think you’re taking a big risk by criticizing yourself publicly, so be prepared.

But when you share the AI Whoops stories with your executive, don’t share the name of the person who told the story. You just want to make it easy for them to understand what the facts on the ground are like. When you share the wins, share the names.

Another thing that can help both your team and your boss is to publicly acknowledge when you realize they were right about something and you were wrong.

Gemini_Generated_Image_7ibvcb7ibvcb7ibv

I once had a 3-foot-tall “you were right, I was wrong” statue and gave it to somebody each week. If that’s too corny for you, find another way to acknowledge when you're wrong and prove you actually appreciate being told so. You want to do this with your employees, your peers, and your boss.

 

Old Question, New Relevance

This article is based on a question we got from one of our readers several years ago–a helpful reminder that old problems allowed us to develop a number of the skills we need to manage this AI transformation:

How do you solve the problem of senior executives who tend to shut down and adopt an Obnoxious Aggressive position when faced with criticism? I’ve found that the Obnoxious Aggressive ones are often challenged internally by feelings of embarrassment and/or shame. Over the course of their career, they have been incredibly successful. And then they finally meet a situation that forces them into a place of realizing they have little or no skills and experience to solve an interpersonal management problem. All too often they bury the problem, and then they bury the fact that they have buried the problem making it really hard to bring to the surface without a total nuclear blow-up. What can make this harder is if there is a corporate culture of behaviors designed to avoid shame and embarrassment. These behaviors take the form of policies or actions that prevent individuals, groups, and organizations from experiencing embarrassment or threat. Moreover, as I mentioned above, these defensive routines are “self-sealing.” Because if an action that helps to reduce embarrassment is made public, it would be ineffective. Therefore, it must also be hidden. For an individual executive do you just put on your body armor and just do it? Or do you have another way? When it’s systemically a part of the corporate culture, what then?

—L

L--This is a GREAT question and a hard one. We answered it in this Podcast episode. We hope this helps, and wish you the very best in your efforts to change the culture and am here any time for follow-up questions. Do let us know how it’s going.

 

 

 

Dive Deeper

For you

Kick ass at work without losing your humanity. Check out our Online Courses and Tools for you to work through on your own time.

Check out Public Workshops, AI Coach, and Online Courses →

For your team

Workshops teach the Radical Candor framework and includes hands-on practice. Real scenarios, role play, up to 150 people. Half or full day. Virtual or in person.

Check out team workshops →

FAQs

How do I offer Radical Candor to a senior executive who shuts down when criticized?

The post recommends proceeding with caution when giving upward feedback, especially to executives with a history of Obnoxious Aggressive reactions. Rather than confronting the executive head-on, focus on what you can control: build a culture of self-criticism on your own team first, then use those results as evidence when talking to your boss. Leading by example is far more effective than trying to directly change a defensive executive's behavior.

What is the 'Whoops-a-Daisy' technique and how does it work?

Whoops-a-Daisy is a simple team ritual where a stuffed daisy is placed at the front of all-hands meetings. Team members nominate themselves to share a mistake they made. In exchange, they receive instant forgiveness and help the team avoid the same error. Kim Scott would always come prepared with her own story and, early on, offered $20 to give people 'plausible deniability' for participating. The goal is to normalize admitting mistakes and make it psychologically safe to do so.

Why do senior executives become defensive or Obnoxiously Aggressive when faced with criticism?

According to the post, many executives feel internal embarrassment or shame when confronted with problems they lack the skills to solve — especially interpersonal or management challenges. After years of success, being exposed to a weakness feels threatening. To protect themselves, they bury the problem and hide the fact that they've buried it, creating self-sealing defensive routines that are very difficult to surface without a major blowup.

Is it safe to practice Radical Candor with your boss?

The post is candid about the risks: someone once tweeted at Kim Scott, 'Tried Radical Candor with my boss. Got fired.' The moral obligation to offer Radical Candor applies most strongly when you're the one in authority. When giving feedback upward, it's entirely reasonable to proceed with more caution, read the environment carefully, and build credibility first by modeling the behavior on your own team before challenging those above you.

How can I convince an executive that being open to criticism is a sign of strength?

The post suggests sharing concrete stories of leaders who became stronger by admitting mistakes — for example, Steve Jobs openly saying 'We're not perfect' during the iPhone 4 Antennagate crisis, or CEO James Burke's praised handling of the Tylenol poisonings. You can also draw on Carol Dweck's book Mindset, which shows how a growth mindset leads to better long-term outcomes. Pairing those stories with results from your own team's culture of self-criticism makes the case tangible.

What role does corporate culture play in making upward feedback harder?

When an entire organization is built around avoiding embarrassment, defensive behaviors become systemic rather than individual. The post describes these as 'self-sealing' routines — actions taken to reduce shame that must themselves stay hidden to remain effective. This makes upward feedback extremely difficult because the culture actively suppresses it. In these environments, the best starting point is your own team: demonstrate that openness to criticism produces better results, then use that evidence to make the case upward.

Share your perspective

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

More from Radical Candor

Blog

How to Give Good Feedback: 7 Things to Remember

What Does Good Feedback Sound Like in the Moment? During a class at business school, “Jane” passed a note about “John” that John intercepted. Here’s what it said: “Check out John …

Read more
Blog

Workplace Romance: How Leaders Create a Culture of Consent

What should a workplace romance policy include? When you read the job description for your role, it probably didn’t mention that you should prevent abusive romantic relationships …

Read more
Podcast

The Three Transitions Every Manager Must Master With Russ Laraway 8 | 31

Most people become managers because they were good at their jobs. Then nobody teaches them the new job. Russ Laraway, a former Marine Corps officer, Google and Twitter veteran, …

Read more