Transcript+
[00:00] Kim Scott: Hello, everybody, and welcome to the Radical Sabbatical, where I talk to the authors of books I love and that have had great meaning for me, while the rest of the podcast team is on sabbatical. Today I am thrilled to have with me Russ Laraway, who many of you know and love as much as I do. He wrote a wonderful book, When They Win, You Win. Welcome, Russ.
[00:25] Russ: Hey, thanks. Thanks for having me.
[00:27] Kim Scott: I think Russ, one of the things you and I both learned about writing a book is that it's not the last mile to helping people change their behavior. I got a lot of feedback that people loved the book but they wanted something more. And you helped me long ago and far away build a company that would design talks and workshops, uh, as well as we were trying to build some software. That didn't work out. And you went on to do great things uh at Qualtrics. and elsewhere and wrote a great book, When They Win, You Win. And I think you got the same feedback and you decided to be a coach. So say a couple of words about your coaching and
[01:08] Russ: Yeah, I I it's last mile's a good good way to frame it. I think um there's a person out there who's in a moment and they are wrestling with a thing and they bring that thing in full context, you know, the full the organization around them, their team, the people above them, around them, et cetera, and they need help framing it up, organizing their thinking and and taking action that that matters and and I feel like that's that is the that's the spot where the rubber meets the road. I feel like it's what I was born to do and I've I've really loved it. I've been doing it over a year, I don't even know how a long time now, maybe even getting to close to a couple of years and and for that reason, 'cause it really it feels like I'm the book I know has helped, like I'm proud of it, but I know this helps them with that thing they're struggling with in that moment, um, you know, every month. So really really like it. Yeah.
[01:59] Kim Scott: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. No, I feel the same way about doing the talks and workshops. Uh it's it's you're in person with people, you're talking to them, you're putting your phone in your pocket, looking people in the eye and having real human conversations. And you and I were talking about some of the real human conversations you've been having. And there's an issue that comes up over and over and over again, which I thought we might want to discuss here so that we can help all the all the people listening.
[02:24] Russ: Yeah. Yeah, in fact one of my clients recommended it. She and I got done an hour session and she said we should go back and redo that and record it. Um she had some example of there's a therapist type person out there who does
[02:36] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[02:37] Russ: this where they they they you know protect the the client with voice distortion and and clouding sort of the face, but um and it was we talked through management transitions.
[02:49] Kim Scott: Mm-hmm.
[02:50] Russ: Uh the ki there's kind of three of them, I think, that you know, there's Probably more, but three that really matters. Of course, the first time you become a manager. There's then when you become a manager of managers.
[03:03] Kim Scott: Mm.
[03:03] Russ: And for my money, those two are on the same evolutionary path, but then there's becoming an executive, which to me felt like it
[03:09] Kim Scott: Totally different. Yeah.
[03:10] Russ: was something else. It was something else entirely. And I think that what's interesting fr for all this for me is I think the transition from frontline To second line gets a lot of attention. I don't know that it's fully justified.
[03:25] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[03:26] Russ: Um, and the executive one, I think a lot of people just don't understand how different it is. So I'm gonna kind of turn it over to you here in one sec, but to just clear the first management transition, like for
[03:37] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[03:38] Russ: me, you go from caring about your own success on one
[03:41] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[03:41] Russ: day. I'm not saying people are selfish, they're good teammates, you know, all that stuff. Like we don't need
[03:45] Kim Scott: good people. Most people are good people. The vast majority of
[03:47] Russ: But you're
[03:47] Kim Scott: people, yeah.
[03:48] Russ: as an individual contributor, your job is to make yourself successful. Be a good teammate, make yourself successful. The day you become a manager, in my opinion, that flips to your job is about everyone else's success.
[04:01] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[04:02] Russ: And I think we could say that sentence. It's an easy sentence to say. It's actually
[04:06] Kim Scott: Hard mind shift.
[04:08] Russ: quite hard to do, right? So it's kind of that much. Deliver an aligned result. Enable the success of the people on your team. That's the manager job description, you know, that I kind of wrote in the book. But I guess where I was hoping to start, we can kind of come back to that. I was hoping to start is this transition from frontline to second line.
[04:29] Kim Scott: And by that y by that
[04:29] Russ: I he all the time.
[04:30] Kim Scott: by that you mean explain for folks what do you mean by that.
[04:32] Russ: Because going from managing individual contributors to managing managers, let's say. You know, you could say from manager to director. There's there's
[04:36] Kim Scott: Yeah, yeah. Yeah.
[04:39] Russ: a lot of ways to frame this. It gets so much attention. I personally don't think the attention's justified, but I was wondering if you have any thoughts on why do you have any thoughts on why people get so wrapped up about this particular change?
[04:52] Kim Scott: Yeah, so I have a theory, but but poke holes in it. My theory is this when people become a manager for the first time, they rarely get trained. They just get a new title. And so if you've been a salesperson, you've had years of sales training. If you're an engineer, you probably spent at least four years in undergrad studying computer science. Or you you've you spent a long time developing those individual contributor skills, whatever they are. If you're a lawyer, you went to law school, et cetera, et cetera. And then all of a sudden you become a manager for the first time with zero training. And even if you went to business school, you got no tr you got training at business school about strategy and finance and all that kind of stuff, but you did not, at least I got none. I don't know if you had any, on how to manage people at business school. Is that
[05:45] Russ: Yeah, we I got a tiny bit. I gravitated to we had a a a managing people at work class that was pretty good, but but pretty theoretical.
[05:51] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[05:52] Russ: And then my favor one of my favorite classes was a leadership class taught by a guy I adore named Michael Useem. He's written a couple books.
[05:59] Kim Scott: yeah.
[05:59] Russ: But but nothing that nothing that I I mean I'd learned how to manage people in the Marines and business school didn't Yeah,
[06:06] Kim Scott: Yes. The the military doesn't yeah.
[06:09] Russ: business school didn't do much to didn't add much. I agree with you. Yeah, I agree with you. Yeah.
[06:12] Kim Scott: Yeah. So now all of a sudden you you've been thrown in the deep end as a manager. And if you sink, you know, the your basic training is sink or swim. But the problem is if you sink, it's not just you who's sinking. You're dragging a whole team of five or ten or fifteen people down with you. And that's a that's expensive. And why why there's not new manager training at every place that promotes anyone to manager, I can't explain. Uh and it's very hard for it's hard to sell. I mean, I've been trying to convince a lot of companies to to like really even two days. Like, give these people two days of tr won't won't happen. And
[06:52] Russ: Yeah.
[06:52] Kim Scott: and so then all of a sudden these people who weren't trained as managers, they somehow they haven't totally sunk, but now they're managers and managers still with no training. And now if they sink, they're gonna drag not five, ten or fifteen people down with them, but 25, 50 or 100 people down with them. And I think I think that's why there's so much focus on, now you're a manager or managers, now we really better train you because the cost of failure has just gone up exponentially. But the facts of the matter is they should the the problem, I think the reason there's so much focus is that they're they're they're fixing a problem that they should have fixed when the these folks were promoted to manager in the first place.
[07:35] Russ: Okay, so the cost goes up a lot and you really probably haven't even really had time to hone your capabilities, never got formally trained on what works and
[07:45] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[07:46] Russ: and and now the you're mo you're way more you're way more leveraged. Your blast radius increases and you'd like it to be a nice positive rainbow blast radius, but instead it's your nuclear bomb bl okay. That actually makes a lot of sense. I
[07:55] Kim Scott: Yeah. It's yeah. That's a that's my theory.
[08:00] Russ: it's a good theory. I I I um it's probably right. I I um For my money, I I don't mean to oversimplify it, but but I am I'm gonna. um If
[08:11] Kim Scott: Okay, it's useful.
[08:12] Russ: the job description, again oversimplified, what one of the things I did in my book was I mocked people making everything too complicated, and so I said, if I'm gonna mock that, I have to simplify. So if the manager job description at every level, by the way, is to deliver an aligned result and enable the success of the people on your team, when you're managing individual contributors, frontline management, You know, you're really helping them to be successful by coaching them on the work and the behaviors. The work and the behaviors. The work is individual contributor work. By definition, right? When you become a manager, manager, that job, in my opinion, doesn't change at all. Except the content, when you're helping be successful, now you need to help people be successful at managing. That's the work. And then the behaviors are are a little different. You know, your core values, those are the behaviors I'm talking about. And you're right, like if you put your theory into that context, you can see why people get so anxious because I have to coach people on how to manage and I've never been taught. I haven't
[09:10] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[09:10] Russ: necessarily had time to hone my capabilities and now here I am having to teach teach it because there's no one else to teach it. I I guess I could see why that gets people kind of excited.
[09:20] Kim Scott: Yeah. I think also part of the problem is that when you become a manager you get a little bit of power. And, you
[09:28] Russ: No.
[09:28] Kim Scott: know, absolute power corrupts absolutely, a little bit of power, you know, also isn't so good for a person. And so sometimes people who when they get promoted to managers start behaving in ways that are uh, you know, not ideal. And and it's not because they're bad people, they just it's because a system has not taught them how to lay that power down, get on a level playing field and build real human relationships. And so they've maybe learned some bad lessons over time as managers. And now it's about to get much, much worse.
[10:05] Russ: Yeah. I'm a big fan of the reluctant manager. As soon as someone
[10:08] Kim Scott: Yes.
[10:08] Russ: tells me they're I'm not a man I won't ever be you know, there's uh you know the movie Gladiator? I know you don't really watch many movies, but do you know it? okay, alright. Uh
[10:14] Kim Scott: I do. I d I I've started watching movies now, actually. Yeah, I I got you know, I'm getting old and tired, so I'm
[10:23] Russ: Can't see the books anymore. All that, yeah. so there's uh it's one of it's Caesar, one of the Caesars in the beginning, um, which sets the whole movie going. He asks Maximus to be his successor. Maximus is the general that leads the army, played by Russell Crowe. Maximus, because he respects you know Caesar, who's really the head of Rome, um, he thinks about it. He doesn't want to do it. He's not a politician, he's a general, and he's a great general. And um he comes back and he says, Thank you, sire, but I can't. And then and then Caesar goes, I'll it's my fate one of my favorite lines, he goes, when when he turns down becoming the emperor of Rome, Caesar goes, You see, Maximus, that is why it must be you. Right? And so people who are not power seeking.
[11:15] Kim Scott: Yes.
[11:15] Russ: Make the best managers and when you become a manager learning how to lay that power down to disempower yourself, knowing you can never fully escape the actual relative power advantage you have is like one of the most important things. Never enhance your power, always try to reduce it. I think. I agree with you there.
[11:31] Kim Scott: Yeah. Share it. Yeah. Share it. empower people, not yourself. what should companies, when they promote people to manager for the first time, what should they be teaching them? so that they don't have this problem. So in an ideal world, A company is gonna promote someone to manager, what exactly should they teach them? And then what's new about being a manager of manager?
[11:55] Russ: there's a lot of really interesting topics that you can teach managers. Um you can imagine a basic course and an advanced course you can imagine lots of ways to do this. Um I I I uh you know what what my book is more than anything is an expression of what we measured works.
[12:14] Kim Scott: Yes.
[12:15] Russ: You know, six thousand person, global, thirty office companies, six hundred managers at our peak,
[12:20] Kim Scott: our being Qualtrics.
[12:21] Russ: yeah, sorry, a Qualtrics, yeah. Yeah, and I had a good sandbox there. Um a founder who was really into all this and and um and we were able to sort of, in my opinion, we were able to take a lot of the what I'd say the number one thing I learned is we too often fall in love with the fancy with respect to leadership at the expense of the simple and effective.
[12:39] Kim Scott: Yeah. Yeah.
[12:42] Russ: And it boiled down, Kim, it boiled down to honestly Really just two things. In fact, if you think about that phrase, deliver an aligned result, enable the success to people on your team. Deliver an aligned result, well, in order for it to be aligned, the first thing a manager has to be great at is giving or or providing clear direction so that everyone knows exactly what is expected of them. Now that could be done collaboratively, it should be done collaboratively, all those things. But I can't tell you the number of people I I could tell, just skip that part of my book, direction.
[13:14] Kim Scott: Yeah, yeah.
[13:15] Russ: And they shouldn't have because they believe they've been crystal clear about what's expected. And in reality, it's probably one of the biggest things getting in the way of a fully effective team. And then enable the success of the people on your team. That's coaching. That's you. That's what that's the biggest thing that's come out. Routecanner's the biggest book about this in the world in a decade. And it's coaching to continue, praise, and it's coaching to improve, criticism. And uh boy, if a if a manager
[13:40] Kim Scott: And soliciting, part of laying your power down is don't dish it out before you prove you can take it. soliciting it before you give it.
[13:47] Russ: Yeah, listening to the team, like you always say, they're they're the ones closest to the facts, closest to the code, closest to the copy, closest to the financial model, closest to the customer service tickets, et cetera, et cetera. Uh, it's really important to hear their perspective, both on how things are working as well as what are our opportunities to succeed, as well as what should be our team direction and what should be your direction. All these things you have to solicit out of the team because they're in a position to offer something really valuable. Because they're close like you always say, they're closer to the facts. So I I would just say, like, I don't think it needs to be more complicated than that. At first, there's things down the line, as an executive, you really gotta learn how to sell a decision like it's your own. And we could come to that. Like, you gotta learn that as a young manager too, but I'd say in terms of explanatory power that will make you successful or not, you gotta learn how to be real clear about what's expected, and you gotta learn how to coach people to that expectation. If you just can just do that with each individual on your team. You're gonna do okay, I think. Here's the thing though, I I don't the training isn't enough. I I'm sure it is. Um, you get you gotta turn around, you gotta measure whether managers are behaving in alignment with what you expect you how you expect them to behave.
[14:55] Kim Scott: Yes. Are they actually doing it?
[14:59] Russ: Yeah, and that's tricky, it's really interesting. That's that's where I think an organization makes its money. I'll just, without going too far in the soapbox, forget all the stuff I just said about you know, given direction and behavior. When we started measuring. What managers were doing, we started asking their employees if they were demonstrating certain behaviors. Do you know the first thing to change? Do you have any can you guess what the first thing to change was? It has nothing to do with the cool stuff I just said. The first thing that changed.
[15:28] Kim Scott: The managers paid more attention to their employees, I'm guessing.
[15:32] Russ: They stopped skipping one-on-ones. I didn't
[15:36] Kim Scott: that's good.
[15:37] Russ: I didn't ask about that. Um and you know, there's this thing where managers skip one-on-ones because whatever pressures come, you know, sometimes managers are deadbeats and sometimes they're good people who just pressures, you know. They shouldn't do that. my opinion. You gotta, you know, maybe a customer thing. Maybe, that's it. Um And then that becomes a habit. And then that manager is never really held accountable because is their employee gonna tattle to the manager's boss about that? That sounds so small, or they're scared, they can't.
[16:01] Kim Scott: No yeah. Yeah.
[16:04] Russ: So the manager's manager never sees that. And then but suddenly when you give the employees this voice, a small voice by the way, in the overall sort of like evaluation of the manager, um all of a sudden managers stop skipping their one-on-one. Like it was amazing, it the most amazing thing I'd ever seen. It was not my intent, but it that
[16:21] Kim Scott: Measure what matters.
[16:22] Russ: overnight, yeah, overnight. They uh I we added it as a question later um about the managers making the one because was so powerful of a of a finding. Um yeah, so so you know that for me, the behavior change I I saw really came from measurement, displaying the measurements. We didn't use it punitively. I I've told you this before. We used it as a coaching tool. It took took a while for the organization to find its footing, but now all of a sudden, when you could see for this team. You always say feedback's measured at the listener's ear, not at the speaker's mouth. These managers are sure they're doing everything right. And here's their team telling them, I never heard you give me feedback. I never heard you help me set my goals. I never heard you and it's like the manager's like, sure they did, but the team never heard it. And now we can close that gap. That that was it. So the managers knew what they were supposed to do, thought they were doing it, but learned the employees weren't hearing it. And that closing that gap is I think best done through measurement. And and
[17:19] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[17:19] Russ: solicitation, but But measurement really for us at scale helped us improve our managers
[17:23] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[17:24] Russ: at scale over time.
[17:25] Kim Scott: So measuring is something the executives had to set up. So let's so let's let's get to that in a second. I wanna I wanna go back to like let's imagine we've got hundreds of people listening to us who have just become a manager for the first time and they heard what you said about goal setting and and creating a culture of feedback, but they're not sure what that means. So let's talk for a minute about goal setting. You you and I had an interesting example w of goal setting when we worked together at Google. At first, I thought it was my job to set the goals for the team. And I would, I know, at the beginning, at the end of every quarter, in preparation for the next quarter, uh, you know, create a big theme and set the goals. And you and Scott Sheffer came to me and said, We're taking this job away from you. You remember this? Yeah.
[18:14] Russ: Did we?
[18:16] Kim Scott: A and and and you Scott really led this, uh but you you helped you helped him convince me that he was right. Uh Scott Sheffer, who worked with us, and he said OKRs have gotta be bottoms up. It can't be top down. If you sort of set clear goals, if you want people to believe in them and you don't give people an opportunity to give you feedback about those goals, they're gonna ignore them, which made sense to me. And so It wasn't even like you and Scott and the rest of the team who set the goals. So we had people set their own goals and and then it rolled up. So we were the editors, not the authors of the goal. So by the time the quarter began, we had very clear goals, but we hadn't necessarily provided direction. We had aligned on direction by going back and forth. with the team. in retrospect, what do you think of that process? somebody has just been promoted to manager. You say your first job is to to make sure that everybody understands the goals. How do they do that?
[19:22] Russ: Well, you know, it's funny, I when I when I've done my talks in the past, there's a question I ask, true or false? A manager's job is to set direction. And it's a trap. it's an obvious trap. I I don't think I'm some s evil genius. Um people say true. Uh it's you know, and it's not, it's false. Um and it's a nuance. I say, no, a manager's job is not set direction, it's to ensure that direction is set.
[19:44] Kim Scott: Yes.
[19:44] Russ: Which is a way that I that I can lead into you gotta bring in bottoms up. I I will say one of the things that Ryan Smith did really well with Qualtrics. Ryan Smith
[19:53] Kim Scott: Mm-hmm.
[19:54] Russ: was the CEO when I was there. Now he has the Utah Jazz and the Utah Mammoth. It went okay.
[19:57] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[19:58] Russ: He brought every January he brought the top 80 or so people in the company off-site to Sundance down there in Provo,
[20:05] Kim Scott: Mm-hmm.
[20:06] Russ: Utah. And there was a really nice give and take between some bottoms-up and just some things we had to get to. We run an IPO track. uh And then after we were bought, we were we we were beholden to certain things that didn't make sense for it all to be bottoms up in the company. There had to be some, executive oversight. In fact, he is responsible for everything the organization does or fails to do. And so of course it makes sense that there has to be some executive oversight. So I want to be a little careful for our frontline managers and give the impression that I don't love this phrase, it's been used to describe this before. It's not the inmates who are the asylum. It's giving the team a big voice in the direction. But the manager has to be conscious that that the manager's direction deliver an aligned result. Well, who are you aligning to? You have to align to your boss, your boss's
[20:52] Kim Scott: Yeah. Yeah.
[20:53] Russ: boss, you have to align to the people to your beside you. And so ultimately you have to exercise managerial discretion to make sure the agenda for the team is aligned. We were in a unique spot at Google in that there just wasn't a ton to align to. You know, we We we were a really unique business. We didn't look like anything else in the company. And so we had a lot of discretion to drive our own agenda. And so it just depends kind of where you find yourself in the organization. But ultimately, what you'll be given as a frontline manager is some sense of what your boss is signed up for. You
[21:27] Kim Scott: Mm.
[21:27] Russ: should go find a sense of what your peers are signed up for. And I think somewhere in there should give you a sense of what you're really signed up for. Now what should now turn to the team? Perhaps and say, what are the goals we should have in order to achieve those things? And what else should we be achieving? And now we've got a nice mixture of bottoms-up ownership, and we've got the reality of an organization, which is we are beholden to we have to achieve some some portion of what our boss has to achieve. Um, something like that, I think, really works and gets us a nice, and let's get that down to three to five measurable goals. More is not better here. Measurable is better than not measurable or binary. Yeah, you know, did you do it or not? And let's just run at that as hard as we can for 13 weeks and see where we land. Something like that.
[22:12] Kim Scott: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. you can correct my memory, but here's what I remember used to happen. So after you all took the job of setting the key results away from me, what would happen is I would go talk to my peer in engineering, I would talk to my peer in product, I'd talk to my peer in marketing, I'd look at whatever grandiose goal Eric Schmidt had. And so he had big goals and and so then in the first year where you all took away the key results from me, I was allowed to express a theme. So one year it was this is the year of operational efficiency.
[22:52] Russ: Yeah.
[22:52] Kim Scott: And then for the international team, you would create kind of a sub theme, and then each of the managers reporting to you would create a sub theme. And then their direct reports would say, here's what I'm gonna do. And there would be some back and forth. And then we published it all. you kind of had to squint a little bit. It wasn't like perfectly aligned. But there were two things that were good. It created a back and forth conversation, a two-way conversation, not a here's where we're going, here's the hill, you know. And it it it also then made transparent what everybody was trying to do. the other thing that was good about it is we didn't say, you're not gonna get your bonus if you don't hit your OKRs. In fact, if you hit more than eighty percent of your OKRs, you're not sitting setting aggressive enough once. So it was it was a little loosey goosey, but I I think it worked reasonably well.
[23:41] Russ: Yeah. Yeah, I think it was pretty good. Yeah, it's just reminded me of a funny story. A product manager at Google, he's a really good guy. I don't think he quite ever found his footing. And we had lunch one day. you know I'm I'm in I'm in I'm in like several years in now and so is he and I'm I'm I have a seven hundred or whatever person group and he's he's still finding his footing. And he said, why can't I he he's the kind of person that could pull this off, but it's such a naive question. He said, why can't I just listen to what Larry and Sergei want to get done, and then why can't I just go and figure something out that supports that? And go get some engineers that want to work on it. And you know, like this really naive, like, I'm smart enough. I don't need these layers in between me. I don't need all the and so look, somewhere, maybe metaphysically someone might say he's right. You know, but it just didn't represent reality at all. You you have all this stuff between what the company's trying to get done. What you have to get done, I will say it is a crucially important activity for managers to never assume their people can link their work to what the company's doing. You have to go through
[24:47] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[24:48] Russ: and explicitly, because tail as old as time, I don't I don't really know how my stuff fits in. uh
[24:53] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[24:55] Russ: And that feels terrible. uh And it is a manager's job to make explicit exactly how. stuff contributes, fits into what the company is trying to get any any kind of higher organization, it is important to do that. But I always found that funny, just given what we're talking about here, how you
[25:10] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[25:10] Russ: have to align and and massage and fit in and look, sometimes it feels like you got ten pieces out of the wrong jigsaw puzzle box, you know, and and you
[25:18] Kim Scott: Yeah. Yeah.
[25:19] Russ: still gotta try to get 'em get those to fit. I've done it. I've I put the wrong pieces in and just said, screw it.
[25:24] Kim Scott: So so those are some stories about setting goals. if you're listening and you're a new manager, another thing that someone told me once that was very helpful about goal setting is that you, as the manager, you're not the author of the goals. Your team has to author their own goals, but you do get to edit them. So you get to review them and say, This seems a little low, this seems a little aggressive, you'll never achieve that and you'll be frustrated. And and then as you say, Russ, you've gotta explain to people how it lines up to whatever the CEO or your manager is saying. And you've got to do that in a you may disagree with the direction that is being set at the company. And this is the hard thing about being a new manager. Because what's the what if you think the CEO's goal, I mean, I is BS. What's the worst thing you can do and what's the best thing you can do? Or your boss's
[26:18] Russ: Yeah.
[26:19] Kim Scott: let's say you think your boss's goal is ridiculous and your team Yeah.
[26:24] Russ: Yeah, yeah, you can never, ever say that. Um yeah, it's uh you have to treat every decision as if it's your own. Uh you go in there, you debate, you argue. Um, greatest compliment I was ever paid was by a battalion commander in the Marines. He wrote my fitness report. Captain Laraway is willing to wave the BS flag when no one else is. But then he said, I just wish he'd put it down once in a while. And it's and it's
[26:50] Kim Scott: Mm that is good feedback.
[26:52] Russ: this By the way, this is my feedback my entire career, as you know, trust me, Richard knows. And so, um, and so anyway, um, you have to go in there and debate, but then you have to turn around and pass it on like you made the decision. This is one of the hardest things we ask managers to do. And the example
[27:07] Kim Scott: Yes.
[27:07] Russ: I give, just to give you the hardest example, you wake up on a Tuesday and you have twenty-four hours to communicate a layoff you did not know was coming. You don't have to lie, but you do you do have to go find out what you need to find out in order to sell this decision. Um, your job is to sell that decision. So if I'm gonna say you have to sell that decision, of course I'm gonna say you have to sell your boss's zany idea about what we should be doing. And it's in your best interest. If you undermine your boss, or as a friend of ours might say, talk shit about your boss, you actually you're actually doing it to yourself. First, you're training your team that they can do that to you.
[27:47] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[27:47] Russ: And it gets more important as you become as you manage more and more managers. and but you also convey you're not the source of power and you start training people to go around you.
[27:57] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[27:58] Russ: Like, okay, well the boss is you know crazy. So then people just start going to the boss uh a little more often, you know. And so there's a couple really big reasons why you really just shouldn't do that. Um, not the least of which is you're you didn't succeed in changing it before. Telling your team it's nutty isn't gonna change it. And now all you've
[28:17] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[28:18] Russ: done is create misery and confusion and it's just it's just a mess versus
[28:22] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[28:22] Russ: getting what you need to really sell it. So worst thing you do, talk trash. Best thing you do, pretend like you made the decision yourself, learn how to sell it. Um because you're not changing it. You didn't, you failed to. You tried, you failed to, and now we gotta go execute it with enthusiasm. Um that's very difficult. Very difficult.
[28:40] Kim Scott: And and and one of the things that is really good about being willing to to wave the BS flag is that you're you're sort of listen challenging and then when you put it down you're committing to do it to do it their way. And the benefit of listening and challenging is that then you understand, even if you don't agree with the decision, you understand the logic of the decision well enough that you can explain the logic of the decision, And that That way you're not lying, you're still being radically candid. You're saying, here, let me I I talk to my boss about this, you know, whatever their name is, and I want to explain to you their logic. You don't have to say, I disagree with it. I think it, you know, you don't have to poke holes in their logic, but you're showing their work. And and if someone then says to you, Do you agree with this? Say this is a decision that has been made. it doesn't matter whether I agree or disagree, here's the logic, here's where we're going. So you don't
[29:40] Russ: Yeah.
[29:40] Kim Scott: have to lie, you can still be radically candid with your team, but being radically candid doesn't mean sharing every doubt you ever have, right? Yeah.
[29:50] Russ: Yeah, yeah. It's really tricky. It is the hardest thing we ask managers to do.
[29:55] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[29:56] Russ: people have a visceral reaction when I when I articulate it as it's not disagreeing commit. I don't I actually think that is a classic example of corporate dilution of a really important idea that comes from the military. Disagree and commit, I just I saw a post from an executive uh where there was a big unpopular decision made. He'd advocated for the more popular position. When they were rolling it out, he said, I realized that I needed to quit or disagree and commit. And so I said, I'm gonna disagree and commit, right? Ms. Mr. Courage out here. But then well it's years later, it's years later, but yeah, he's absolutely for sure getting it on
[30:27] Kim Scott: Yeah, but then he's just telling everybody he thinks it's a bad idea. Okay. Yeah.
[30:33] Russ: the record. He advocated because it was a tough rollout. And then but then he said, and so I disagreed and committed. I told my team I advocated for the popular position, and I'm like, you didn't disagree and commit. You just didn't. You
[30:43] Kim Scott: No no.
[30:45] Russ: You you just told everybody you advocated for the more popular position, thereby undermining it was more comfortable for he really thought he was doing it. And by the way, it's some pretty successful major companies you've heard of and has no idea that that's not the standard. That's why I like to teach the standard as pass on every decision as if it's your own. Get the logic, get what
[31:05] Kim Scott: Yeah. Yeah.
[31:06] Russ: you need to sell it, understand you're gonna maybe even have a rough time with it, but it doesn't change the fact that your job You gotta explain, sell, whatever word you wanna use. And talking about the inside baseball or the sausage making behind the scenes and what you really wanted is all irrelevant. We're doing this now. Let's go do this. Yeah. So
[31:23] Kim Scott: Yes. This is where we're going. Yeah.
[31:28] Russ: tricky, tricky. Hardest thing we ask managers to do. Yeah.
[31:30] Kim Scott: Really hard. Yeah. Okay. So that's good. That's goal setting. So so for folks who are new managers, goal setting. And also, by the way, goal setting, this is everything you just talked about is relevant to managers managers and to executives, which is why we need to t teach it correctly in the first place. So what's the second thing that folks who are listening who are brand new managers who've not been trained on management at their company, which is probably ninety five percent of new managers,
[31:56] Russ: Everyone.
[31:57] Kim Scott: what's the what's not every so a few companies do, good job, but Uh but what's the second thing that folks need to learn?
[32:04] Russ: Yeah, just coaching to those to those to the direction that we've set together. And this is I d I don't deserve a minute to talk about this on your podcast. This is like
[32:14] Kim Scott: Ha
[32:15] Russ: ultimate Kim Scott wheelhouse. you like praise and criticism. I I like it too, but I rather intentionally went away from those words because The the underlying true value of praise isn't so much recognition, it's it's being clear about what's expected. and so I chose to frame that as continue, but I probably chose continue mostly because I didn't really want to use the word criticism. I know a lot of people fear it, but the reason is I think it gets in the way. If you can get a little bit squared away in your head, that my job is to deliver an aligned result and to enable the success of the people on my team. I am going to talk to them about what they should improve in order to make them more successful. I do have a feeling maybe that lowers the barrier to giving tough feedback a bit. I there's no silver bullet. I I'm not
[32:59] Kim Scott: Yeah. Yeah.
[33:01] Russ: I'm not naive. But that's it. We're doing two things. We're giving them continued coaching or improved coaching on only two things: behaviors and work. So behaviors are usually expressed by like our core values, they're how we expect
[33:15] Kim Scott: Mm-hmm.
[33:16] Russ: to behave um with each other. As we do that, that creates our culture. The work is the work we do. uh That might be running the customer meeting, that might be writing the code, that might be writing the marketing copy, that might be handling the customer service ticket, whatever. And sort of in between those two things, we have to tell people what they should keep doing because it's working and it's what we expect, and we have to tell people what they should improve. And radical candor philosophy, doing those things as quickly as possible helps people to make the changes. to be successful more quickly or to repeat the things that they've been doing well. I feel I mean I just stole all that from you, but um but that's that's the other major thing we have to do is enable people's success through coaching.
[34:03] Kim Scott: Yeah, yeah. Ross, I really like the challenge on praise and criticism. Cause criticism is one of those words that means so many different things to so many different people. And I think for example, it's like criticism is considered one of the four horsemen of uh relationship doom so so I think when some people hear criticism, what they think it means is name calling. And that's obviously not what I'm encouraging people to do. it's a good it's an important nuance. But I w
[34:32] Russ: Yeah.
[34:32] Kim Scott: also want to talk about soliciting criticism because I think that you're as good at doing that as anybody I've ever met in my career. when I do a workshop, I almost always quote you because I think the hardest thing about soliciting criticism is when you disagree with the criticism that you got. So then what do you do? And my advice to folks is listen for the five or ten percent that you agree with and give voice to that. And then have a respectful conversation about why you disagree with their with their feedback. And the thing that is most helpful. to people when I describe how to do this is something you used to say to your team, which or probably still do, is if we have the data, you know, we're having this disagreement and when we're getting we've had the disagreement and now we've got a commit, you would say, if we've got the data, let's do what the data says. But if all we have are opinions, let's go
[35:32] Russ: Pinions.
[35:33] Kim Scott: with yours. your employees opinion, not you you weren't saying, I'm the boss, so we're gonna go with my opinion.
[35:40] Russ: Right.
[35:40] Kim Scott: So talk a little bit about how you came up with that.
[35:43] Russ: Yeah, well it's the the actual real quote comes from Jim Barksdale, who founded Netscape. Well he was saying it the other way. He he was
[35:46] Kim Scott: Yes, who who who is not saying the right thing? Yeah.
[35:51] Russ: saying, if all if we have the data, let's talk about data, if all we have are opinions, let's go with mine. That's what he said. Um and I all
[35:55] Kim Scott: Yeah. He was picking his he was picking his power up. You were laying your power
[36:00] Russ: Yeah,
[36:00] Kim Scott: down.
[36:01] Russ: yeah, that's it. That's the difference. Jim Barksdale is probably more worth listening to than me on almost everything. I just disagree with him on this.
[36:08] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[36:09] Russ: Because I do believe folks are closer to the facts. I I really, really believe that. I'm never confused. I am beholden to what my boss needs me to get done. Like I we're just not gonna escape that. But the degrees of freedom we have within that to get meaningful things done, I really feel like the most important perspective comes out of the team. I always have. Uh it was true in the Marines. Most people don't even most people don't understand or believe that. It's not tell them to jump, they j say how high it was. How do you think, Sergeant, we should get this done? And that's usually where the best answer was. I had to make it work within my context, but that's so I really believe that. Yeah, if we got the
[36:45] Kim Scott: So so so for
[36:46] Russ: data, let's go with data. If all we have our opinions, let's go with yours. Um the best person at I just I just thought a woman that worked for me at Qualtrics named Alexis Lopez. I remember after about maybe six months or so, I said, I turned to her. We always sat next to her. She ran my people analytics team, which was for me the most important thing
[37:05] Kim Scott: Mm-hmm. Yeah.
[37:07] Russ: I had going. So I sat right next to her always and I said, Alexis, you are really good at both asking for and then accepting this improvement coaching, better than anyone I've seen, just somehow with almost no defensiveness. And she said like, like I said, the craziest thing on earth. She said, wait, You're gonna tell me how I can perform better and I'm not gonna wanna hear that? Like why wouldn't I wanna hear that? I was like, well yeah, it's just most people we that's not how and and I remember the mind I was like, gosh, that mindset. You know, she was an athlete. I think sometimes athletes have a little advantage there. She played, you know, AAU basketball and stuff growing up. And so she had been used to the idea of improvement coaching in the name of making me more successful. She didn't have a lot of hangups that there's maybe something else. Tar. Like she just made it so simple. I was like, all right, great, then this is gonna work because I really don't feel like I'm criticizing. I just feel like we can make all the work better. You can make mine better, I can make yours better. I'm happy for it to be give and take. But boy, meeting con getting someone on the opposite side of the table with that mindset is gold
[38:13] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[38:14] Russ: and made it real, really easy. And then eventually she became comfortable giving me improvement feedback. You know, she was my best my she was my best listening post, you know, eventually
[38:23] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[38:23] Russ: because She got so comfortable with it. So yeah, I think there's a lot. I think there's a lot there.
[38:28] Kim Scott: Yeah, yeah. I think that the people who work for you are gonna give you the best feedback 'cause almost no one except your children is watching you as closely. And
[38:37] Russ: Yeah.
[38:38] Kim Scott: and so they're gonna notice everything you do wrong. And if you can make it safe and not only safe, but if you can reward them for telling you what you're doing wrong, that's that's gonna be your best s path to success. 'Cause They're gonna they're gonna help you. Okay, so we spent ninety percent of our time talking about new manager training, and I think that's correct because that's where ninety percent uh all of this stuff in new manager training applies to the next two steps. what changes when you become a manager of managers. What skills do you need to add to your toolbox when you become a man
[39:13] Russ: If if it's okay, can we leapfrog that? Because I I feel like for me, I've given that all the treatment I care to give it. I don't believe it's a meaningfully different job. I understand it feels very different. I just don't really believe it is. I really the executive stuff's so interesting and I think is although probably most of the audience it's not immediately actionable for them, I think it's just so interesting to hear.
[39:34] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[39:35] Russ: And I've heard a couple times now through my coaching. just sort of looking out at the sunset of what they might one day be to start to understand how different that might be. So I if if we can then if you want to come back to manager managers, we can. All
[39:43] Kim Scott: Let's do it. Sold. Unsold. Yep.
[39:48] Russ: right. so I've been thinking about this a ton because I went through it, you know, and that journey really started with uh the boss I got after you left Google, Margo Dirgatis, who basically
[40:00] Kim Scott: Mm-hmm.
[40:01] Russ: said, you like the long version of the story. Um Always. And she's like, look, you've been rewarded till now on your details. And I understand this place. This was at Google. It's
[40:12] Kim Scott: Yeah. Yeah.
[40:14] Russ: nuts. And you're rewarded for your details and you gotta know your details, you gotta be able to communicate your details. She's like, if you want to be an executive here, the people that are gonna decide that are the other executives, and you gotta fit in with them. She said they don't have time for your bullshit. And the first thing she really got me to try was top lining. Um, I hated top liners. I thought they were full of shit. I thought they were full of crap people who just said smart things in meetings. I was like, where's the substance? You know, it's the iceberg
[40:43] Kim Scott: Yeah. Yeah.
[40:45] Russ: metaphor. They said the thing above the surface, but there was a good top line. There is real substance beneath. And if someone wants it, they'll interrogate it. I thought and then she sent me on an assignment with the scariest executive at Google where I was only allowed to top line things and and I was sure But that and then two years later, that guy hired me for a job because he remembered that lunch he made me do. It was a really good learning.
[41:06] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[41:06] Russ: But I think like if to give a little structure to this, um the first thing is like, actually I'll I'll give you a little question if you don't mind, put you on the spot. Have you ever thought about really fundamentally what is a team and a company? Have you ever thought about like, what is a team? What what is it?
[41:24] Kim Scott: I think that that a team is
[41:27] Russ: Yeah.
[41:28] Kim Scott: the atomic building block of a company. A team is where the real work gets done and where the real relationships get formed. The team is is where the results happen. That's that's
[41:42] Russ: Yeah, I love it.
[41:42] Kim Scott: is
[41:43] Russ: I'm gonna simplify it into four words
[41:45] Kim Scott: Good.
[41:45] Russ: for the sake of my executive argument.
[41:47] Kim Scott: Okay.
[41:48] Russ: Common goals, results, common activities, right? So the team of accountants, they all do accounting, the team of content marketers, they all do content. If you think about it though, as you move up in an organization,
[42:01] Kim Scott: Mm-hmm.
[42:02] Russ: the teams, the activities begin to become more diverse.
[42:05] Kim Scott: Yes.
[42:06] Russ: Right? So by the time you're an executive. Uh everybody loves to complain that executives don't know what's going on in the organization. Correct. Because the activities, by the time you're an executive, you're not talking about a you know, we're talking in a thousand-person company. The executive has no reason to be able to understand all the details of what's happening in the organization. It makes no sense that they would, actually, because by the time you're at that level, you know, I'm I'm making a very hierarchical body language here, common goals, common activities. Your atomic unit over there in function A
[42:40] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[42:40] Russ: and your atomic unit over there in function F, they're not doing anything that looks at all alike. The chief people officer of company, you have recruiting. You have compensation and benefits. They they link at an offer, right? Don't they? You have legal. You
[42:56] Kim Scott: Mm-hmm.
[42:56] Russ: have the HRBPs. In my opinion, the first thing you should have is people analytics. These things are get organized under the executive for a reason. It's the people function, but the atomic building block from function A to function F, nothing looks alike.
[43:09] Kim Scott: Total yeah.
[43:11] Russ: So the executives in this now d now the executive isn't necessarily familiar with the exact common results of each team and the common activities, especially. So what it what is the job, right? Um the job is systems, in my opinion. I
[43:25] Kim Scott: Yes.
[43:26] Russ: I the number one way to decide whether to hire or promote an executive, in my opinion. The number one thing you have to be able to do is be able to convey that you can work in terms of systems and not details. So that an example, this manager system we built to Qualtrics Kim, I I say all the time, perfection's not a reasonable standard. But I can tell you exactly how imperfect this was. Um so I could measure that our managers were improving measurably. As we added 500 managers, our manager improved. That's incredible.
[43:57] Kim Scott: Yeah. Yeah.
[43:58] Russ: I can measure that the employee experience was improving along 20 dimensions. And yet, guess what was true? 60. 6,000 people, let's say in the company. 60 people, 600 people not having that experience. 600 is 10%.
[44:11] Kim Scott: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
[44:13] Russ: The detail thinker says, I gotta fix that 600. The systems thinker says the error rate's between 1 and 10%. What's the next highest leverage thing I can work on? Now that I'm that's a Conceptual argument I didn't love that I knew there were people in the company whose managers were failing. But where I would get involved if is a very senior person and who was having a bad blast radius. But I but I couldn't be six 600 managers, I couldn't go find every failing. I did trust that our system would ultimately either get this person out or get this person improved. Um and I had to move on to the next thing that was higher leverage.
[44:49] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[44:50] Russ: People don't like that. It's really uncomfortable. By the way, if you have a perfectionism complex, the idea you're gonna leave one to ten percent error in your system that you created really feels uncomfortable. But I'm pretty convinced it's the right mindset. Now you might
[45:04] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[45:04] Russ: decide to accept two percent, or you might decide to accept twenty. I don't it doesn't matter, you get the idea. But it's one of the biggest things, yeah.
[45:09] Kim Scott: Good si Yeah, a good system I think has got to be fault tolerant. Uh otherwise it's gonna be excessively punitive, I think.
[45:19] Russ: Yeah, that's probably I hadn't thought about it that way, but that's probably that's probably right. The the the and then I could we could detail on any of this that you like. The only other thing I would say is the way you communicate has to change radically. And the funny part about this is this sounds like the easiest thing to change. But for people it's the nearest term, realest thing they can do. And this idea that you're gonna stop communicating your details and start toplining, that that's like, obvious. I'm going through it with with a client, um, and it is a massive challenge that requires constant reminding. They're constantly trying to think about their top lines in anticipation of a setting where it'll matter. You have to be able to use story, metaphor, top line, and abstraction over logical and deeply detailed data-driven arguments. You were rewarded for years on that Logical, detailed, data driven. I'm not saying no more data. I'm not saying no more logic. But that's how you're rewarded. Now you gotta go story, abstraction, metaphor, top line. and this is a giant leap of faith for people. Just I say that out loud, you're nodding. What's your what's your reaction to that?
[46:29] Kim Scott: To totally agree. What I'm thinking of, so when I left Google and joined Apple, I taught this class communicating at Apple. And we taught toplining. And the metaphor that we used was this lithograph that Picasso had drawn of a bull. And his first drawing of the bull had a lot of detail. The second drawing had a little less. And then by the ninth drawing, it was just one line. But you could still tell it was a bull. And One of the things that we explained to folks is when you're talking to this executive, you need to draw the bowl one way. When you're talking to that exe like different people need different top lines. And so not only do you need to learn how to communicate what's at the tip of the iceberg, what's relevant at the tip of the iceberg for one person is different than what's relevant for another person. I think another thing that I struggled with certainly is I uh I
[47:25] Russ: R real fast,
[47:26] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[47:26] Russ: that is the best that bull drawing, nine iterations, getting to just the outline. And then your application, the right altitude, I think is a word I like for you. You gotta figure out the right altitude to talk to this person. That is the best metaphor I've heard for this problem of detail to top line. Sorry, I just wanted to that's the best metaphor I've heard. Yeah.
[47:45] Kim Scott: Yeah. Thank you. Uh thank you. it was a fun class to teach. the fact that you end up here doesn't mean you didn't need to draw the bowl with all the detail in the first place. And that
[47:55] Russ: Exactly. Exactly.
[47:57] Kim Scott: that I think was what we had to teach people. And it's hard to do. So there's there's top lining, I think, but I also want to go back to the systems thing.
[48:06] Russ: Mm.
[48:06] Kim Scott: Because I believe you're exactly right. if you are an executive, it is your job to design systems that yield a good outcome. It is your job to design promotion systems, hiring systems, like all of these management systems. but your systems have sort of game dynamics to them. And if you reward the wrong behaviors unintentionally, and often these management systems that people create or the OKR systems that people create reward the wrong behaviors, you're gonna get bad decisions. So if you don't design your systems to be fair, you're gonna get systemic unfairness every single
[48:51] Russ: Yeah.
[48:51] Kim Scott: time and bad decisions What do you think about that assertion?
[48:55] Russ: Uh I think spot on, I think the only thing I just wanna sort of disabuse anyone of the notion that you're e even a really, really good system is going to produce unfair outcomes. The question is at what rate? Yeah.
[49:07] Kim Scott: Ten percent of the time, yes. At least it should get it should get it right more than half the time. Ideally,
[49:13] Russ: Yeah, that's
[49:14] Kim Scott: seventy five percent of the time, it should get it right.
[49:16] Russ: Yeah, and here's the here's the create here's the here's the thing that really stinks. Is let's say we designed a system, you you name it, pay or promotion or whatever, and let's say We could somehow know it's getting 80 plus percent fair outcomes. Let's just pretend.
[49:32] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[49:33] Russ: There are two really there are two really fascinating realities that come off of that. One is um, well, it's really one reality. The 20% Can get pretty vocal pretty fast, and they can make it seem like the system isn't good, isn't producing systematically fair outcomes. Um they might go to blind. Have you ever heard of blind?
[49:54] Kim Scott: Yes.
[49:55] Russ: Cesspool of uh cowardice and ignorance. Um, but it's the most unbelievable thing I've ever seen.
[49:59] Kim Scott: It's it's manipulative intenterity is what yeah.
[50:04] Russ: Uh but you know, people people like to go be cowards and and ignorant, I guess. Um
[50:10] Kim Scott: Well, or they don't feel safe speaking truth to power and so they're using this as an outlet. To be fair.
[50:14] Russ: That's probably why they go there. I've read enough to know it's more than anything, it's cowardice and ignorance. But whatever. Probably just
[50:19] Kim Scott: Okay. uh
[50:20] Russ: insulted a lot of people. Um so, but anyway, there's this there's this funny thing. Tw Twitter is is this idea that I'm about or ex. Uh people when they have the ability to anonymously or pseudon pseudo-anonymously criticize like famous people, like think about Hollywood stars or whatever. they'll do it. they'll do it in some incredibly negative ways, etc., etc. And the truth is they don't really know that person. But they're making a lot of judgments about that person's intent or that person's character, that person's this, that person's that, because the person made some comment they don't agree with or did something slightly wrong or very wrong, whatever. But the liberties people will take about that person's character, judgment, or intent are fascinating. I I realized as an executive at Qualtrics, and by the way, like I'm not like crying sour grapes. I think I was a relatively popular executive. Um but
[51:14] Kim Scott: Yes, I know you were.
[51:16] Russ: but but I had detractors. My number one detractor was this guy never did this job before, you know, which was exactly what the founder wanted, but yeah,
[51:22] Kim Scott: Yeah. That was true, yeah.
[51:24] Russ: it was true. But like that anybody who was having a bad outcome decided
[51:27] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[51:28] Russ: the reason was I had never done the job before, and I could read that on blind. Um so that wasn't ignorance, that was true. Um but but the thing is I noticed is that the More seen you are in an organization, the less likely you are to personally interact with everyone. The less likely, therefore, everyone is to understand your intent, to understand your logic, to understand the actual quality of the system that's been designed and implemented. And you have your moments at an all-hands here where 60% attend, half of those pay attention. Um, you know, maybe you got the last slot and they left. You have your moments where you're supposed to be able to communicate these things, but all the systems together have error. That error compounds, literally multiplies. And then you have this bizarre sort of underbelly of the company that hates that executive or dislikes that executive or is hypercritical that executive because the system's not working. But I just my premise here was imagine we could know it does produce fair outcomes at an 80 or 90% rate. Um that's a fascinating dynamic that my advice is you become executives: guess what you have to do? You have to you have to learn how to ignore that. You have to learn how to be the Hollywood person or the professional athlete that's getting all the criticism. But who just turns around and focuses on what you control and what matters, which is the next system's 80%, or if you want to get five more percent out of the current systems, things like that. And you gotta have like this Teflon aspect to you because the criticisms coming, whether it's justified or not, and it's usually born of ignorance. Um, not always, but often enough born of ignorance because you don't have the ability to get everybody on the same page, even if you try. It's not a realistic
[53:04] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[53:05] Russ: endeavor. It's really tough. Like reality of being executive.
[53:06] Kim Scott: It's really yeah. I remember there was one time when we were working together at Google and and Google's promotion system was was uh it was pretty good actually, I would say, but it was imperfect. Uh and I think, we all struggled with it. so there was a moment where uh a Person asked in an all hands meeting of me, do you think our promotion system is fair? Do you think our rating system is fair? And my response was, there's going to be a lot of times, like 10, 15, 20% of the time, and that's a lot, where it's not fair, where it doesn't get it right. And so if you are not getting the result that you think is fair, I'm not going to tell you that you're wrong. You may be right. In fact, 10, 20% chance, you're correct. You you got an unfair result. And I want to acknowledge that sucks, but it'll never be perfect. And if you share that feedback, it'll come out in the wash. Like overall, Shona Brown, who designed all these systems, is working hard to make them fair. I'm working hard to make sure it's fair. We do a calibration system, and we're humans and we're imperfect. And That was a on the one hand it was a deeply unsatisfactory answer, but it was just the truth. And I think that it worked. I was also talking to someone who is the head of HR at a very fast, one of the fastest growing companies on the planet, maybe in history. I won't say which one. And she was telling me, she said, when I was the head uh I was in HR at another fast growing tech company. And I wasn't getting promoted and I and I didn't think it was fair. And I I went to a lot of people and they sort of were telling me all this stuff I could work on. And finally somebody said to me, It's not fair that you didn't get promoted. Uh, but people just don't see you in that next role, fair or unfair. But that's just and she said it was the kindest thing anyone ever said to her, because all these other people were telling her to do all this BS stuff and making it seem like it was her fault. And just acknowledging that the system wasn't fair was what liberated her to go get this other job and to be successful in her career. So just sometimes acknowledging the system is not fair is okay for an executive to do. It's never gonna be perfectly fair. There's like justice, f fairness, perfection is an engineering accident. It's fault tolerant is what it is.
[55:36] Russ: Yeah. I think like your answer to the team, I think they're satisfactory answers. They're just not satisfying. And it's actually
[55:43] Kim Scott: No, it was a
[55:44] Russ: quite quite difficult for people when it's their personal livelihood, it's harder
[55:47] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[55:48] Russ: for them to absorb the wait, you're telling me there's a possibility that I'm right that it's not fair.
[55:52] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[55:53] Russ: Here's a funny you wanna hear a funny lens to look at Google system when we were there, you know, five to twenty twelve for me, a little bit different time for you. It was too fair. it was it was so fair, it was unfair, and here's how I know. They are right now as a company, their layoffs are almost entirely targeted at upper middle management. and a lot of these people have been there a long time, they have over promoted. This is what the only thing I didn't like about Google's approach was we were never honest, that the constraint was budget, because budget was tricky at Google because for a while we didn't want one or need one. Budget and org shape.
[56:29] Kim Scott: Money was flying out of yeah.
[56:32] Russ: You a a promotion system is beholden to those two constraints: budget and workshape. You can't create the wrong workshape, it's not sustainable. So for all the people who didn't get the outcome they wanted at this moment or that moment, the truth is, and and by the way, they might be right, it might have been unfair. At this moment, there Google's having to lay people off because they over-promoted over the years. They
[56:54] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[56:54] Russ: got the wrong word shape, it's the wrong economics. For a quality business, like kind of systematically, which tells me it was the promotion system that contributed
[57:02] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[57:03] Russ: to it. we were never honest about the constraint in the background. We just weren't. Like, I'm not even sure
[57:06] Kim Scott: Yeah, yeah.
[57:07] Russ: I understood it until I was a chief people officer.
[57:10] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[57:10] Russ: I was like, this the reality behind this is that our promotion in fact what we started to do with Qualtrics was the finance team gave me the budget for promotion.
[57:19] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[57:19] Russ: And then we would set our rates at that and we would evaluate Orgshape very carefully. You had to pay closer attention at higher level promotions, right? And um and somebody be could be kicking absolute butt. But we couldn't justify the orgshape change
[57:35] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[57:35] Russ: that their promotion, and that's a tough that's a really hard conversation. Is it fair?
[57:37] Kim Scott: It's hard. Yeah, really hard. Really hard.
[57:40] Russ: Well, what is fair in that context? They're performing,
[57:42] Kim Scott: Yeah.
[57:43] Russ: they want to be promoted, they want more money, but the organizational constraint is real too.
[57:48] Kim Scott: Like if we Yeah, basically
[57:48] Russ: And nobody likes to hear that, you know.
[57:50] Kim Scott: what you what you have to say to people is if we promote you, we're gonna have to fire you. So So but but who
[57:55] Russ: Something like that.
[57:56] Kim Scott: but I mean that's that's basically what you mean by org shape.
[57:58] Russ: Still wanna get promoted?
[58:02] Kim Scott: Awesome.
[58:02] Russ: Awesome.
[58:02] Kim Scott: Well, Ross, you were so helpful for people who are new managers, for people who are becoming managers of managers, go back and learn that stuff you didn't learn before and for people getting promoted to executive. So always a pleasure to talk. Thank you.
[58:16] Russ: Yeah, you got it.
Transcript lightly edited for readability. Full transcript available on request.
More from Radical Candor
AI Isn’t Passing You By - How to Catch Up (with Jeremy Utley) 8 | 30
Feeling behind on AI? Embarrassed that you don’t know more by now? You’re not alone, and you’re probably more prepared than you think. The people management skills you’ve spent …
Manipulation vs. Persuasion: A Clear Distinction (with Jay Conger) 8 | 29
While the podcast team is on a Radical Sabbatical, Kim Scott is spending the season talking to authors of the books that have shaped her thinking. This week: Jay Conger, whose …
How Can You Confront a Bullying Boss Without Losing Your Job? 8 | 28
Age, failure, succession, death, money, layoffs, race, religion, politics. The list of topics that feel too hot to touch keeps growing. So we avoid them and stick to small talk. …
Share your perspective
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.